Free training

She resents me

What to do when your wife says she's unhappy

By Noah Allen
Author of The Heroic Husband·4 min read

She said "I'm not happy."

Maybe in the car, maybe after the kids went down.

And you typed "what to do when your wife says she's unhappy" because you didn't know what to say back.

First, I'm glad you're taking it seriously.

A lot of men don't until she's a lot further down the road.

Why this one counts

Now most guys hear "I'm unhappy" as a mood.

She's tired, work is rough, it'll pass.

And sometimes it is that.

But usually when a wife says it out loud, she's been feeling it for a while and picked her moment.

Which really means this is her still coming to you with it.

The wives who've given up don't bother.

The two wrong answers

Okay, so most men go one of two ways.

The first is fixing.

"What do you want me to do?", "let's book a trip", "should you see someone?".

The second is defending.

"I'm doing my best", "you think I'm happy?", "nothing is ever enough for you".

To your wife both of those end the conversation she was trying to start.

What she's hoping for

You see, she's hoping you'll want to know more.

She wants you to ask what it's been like and stay calm while she tells you, even when part of it is about you.

That's emotional safety, her being able to say what's on her mind without you getting defensive, over explaining or justifying.

Women look at men as leaders, and a man who can hear "I'm unhappy" without falling apart or blowing up is leading.

What it looks like from her side

Okay, so imagine the moment from where she's standing.

She's thought about it for a while, maybe weeks, and picked a time when she thought she could say it.

Her heart is going when she says "I'm not happy."

Now she's watching your face to see which man she's about to get.

The one who gets curious, the one who gets angry, or the one who goes quiet and disappears into his phone.

You see, a woman needs to feel emotionally safe before she can say the next sentence, and the next one is the one that matters.

So what you do in the first ten seconds tells her whether there's going to be a next one.

What men try first and why it backfires

A lot of guys hear she's unhappy and go straight to doing things for her.

They plan something, take on more of the house, or buy something she'd mentioned.

And those come from love, no question.

But when she says "I'm unhappy" and you hand her a plan, she hears that you want the problem handled so you can feel better.

That's wanting something FROM her, which is for her to stop hurting so you can relax.

What helps is wanting something FOR her, which is for her to feel known by you.

The other thing men do is go looking for the reason.

"Is it work, is it the kids, is it your mom?"

Sometimes she doesn't know yet, and a quiz makes her feel like she has to defend how she feels.

The small moments at home

Look for the small things she's been saying before the big one.

She's quieter at dinner, she says she's tired a lot, she stopped telling you about her week.

She laughs less at your jokes, or stops making jokes back.

Most husbands see all that and tell themselves it's a phase.

Then one night she says the word, and it feels like it came from nowhere.

It didn't, and you can still choose to pay attention now.

Why "happy wife, happy life" doesn't fit

That saying treats her happiness like a thermostat you can adjust.

You can't make another person happy, and trying to do it quietly puts a lot of pressure on her to look happy for you.

What you can do is be someone she doesn't have to manage when she's not.

What I can't tell you

I can't tell you what's making her unhappy, and some of it may not be about you at all.

And I can't promise that listening makes her happy.

But she'll know she can bring it to you, and that's worth a lot to a wife.

One thing to do tonight

So go back to her and say "you told me you're not happy, and I'd like to hear more about that".

Then listen.

Afterwards write down what she said, and what you wanted to say that you didn't.

Keep reading

Back to My wife resents me.

Next: My wife resents me, how do I fix it? and My wife says she feels alone.

Also: My wife is pulling away from me.

Remember it's NEVER too late,

Noah

Questions men ask

What should I say when my wife says she's unhappy?

Ask her to tell you more and then listen without fixing or defending. That's most of it.

Is my wife unhappy with me or with her life?

It could be either or both, and she may not be sure herself. Ask and don't assume.

Does unhappy mean she wants to leave?

She said unhappy and that's all she said. It's a warning worth taking seriously, and it's a long way from her leaving.

How do I make my wife happy again?

You can't make another person happy. You can be easier to talk to and more present, and see what that changes.

Why won't my wife tell me what's wrong?

Often because telling you hasn't gone well before. Show her it's safe a few times and she may say more.

Should we go to counseling if she's unhappy?

If she's open to it, it can help. If she isn't, pushing it turns into pressure, so start with what you can do yourself.

Free training

Watch the free training: the 3 core issues destroying most marriages

Put your email in and you can watch it tonight.

After that you get one short email from me every morning.

Free. Unsubscribe any time.